The following is an imagined conversation among the characters of Seinfeld.
Jerry: Children's Literature, what's the deal?
Elaine: What do you mean? It's books for kids.
Jerry: Yeah, but can only kids read them? What if I want to read one? Is that not allowed?
Elaine: So, you're saying you want to read Dr. Seuss. I say go ahead.
George: I love Dr. Seuss.
Kramer: (bursting through the door) Hey, did somebody say something about Dr. Seuss?
Imaginary Jerry brings up a good point. What is the deal? What is children's literature? Infamous book snob (and critical genius) Harold Bloom, in the introduction to Stories and Poems for Extremely Intelligent Children of All Ages, says, "Most of what is now commercially offered as children's literature would be inadequate fare for any reader of any age at any time." There he goes harping on about universality again, but his point is clear: there's a lot of junky books out there. Assuming that imaginary Elaine is correct, that children's literature is simply books for kids, then what makes for good children's literature? This is a question I'm eager to explore. Tons of smart people (Bloom included) have plenty to say on the topic, but I'm curious about what you think.
So, I've thought back to my own childhood, made a list of books that stand out in my memory, and I'd like you to do the same. These are the books that I remember reading, or in a couple of instances remember them being read to me by a teacher. I figure that's a pretty good measure of the impact the book had on me. I've skipped over the early childhood stuff, but feel free to include those in your own list.
- The Secret of NIMH, by Robert C. O'brien
- The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, by Mark Twain
- The Mouse and the Motorcycle, by Beverly Cleary
- The Trumpet of the Swan, by E.B. White
- The Chronicles of Narnia, by C.S. Lewis
- The Hardy Boys series, by Franklin W. Dixon (pseudonym)
- The Phantom Tollbooth, by Norton Juster
- The Alligator and His Uncle Tooth, by Geoffrey Hayes
- Hatchet, by Gary Paulson
- They Whipping Boy, by Sid Fleischman
Please post a comment with your own "most memorable children's book" list. Also, you can explore these books by checking out my list on Indiebound.
Oh man, I loved "Hatchet". I loved that genre for a while, "My Side of the Mountain", "Where the Red Fern Grows". I never wanted to be a boy scout, but loved some of the visuals created for those books.
ReplyDelete"The Hardy Boys" were great. "The Babysitter's Club": not good and also not good for the pursuit of picking up fellow fifth grade ladies.
*Little House books-Laura Ingalls Wilder
ReplyDelete*Anne of Green Gables-L. M. Montgomery
*Bridge to Terabithia-Katherine Paterson
*Ramona Quimby Series-Beverly Cleary
*The Fledgling-Jane Langton
*Blueberries for Sal-Robert McCloskey
Luke, I read some of the Babysitter's Club books and I remember thinking they were entertaining, but knew that they were not good quality.
*Little House on the Prairie Series (yeah Carrie!)
ReplyDelete*Romona Quimby series (yes again Carrie!)
*Griffin and Sabine trilogy (not children's books, but I read them over and over again as a youngin'.)
*Which Way Freedom by Joyce Hansen (historical fiction that rocked my hot pink socks off)
*Letters From Rifka by Karen Hesse (another historical novel composed of letters, so good!)
*Are You There God? It's Me Margaret by Judy Blume. (This is my all-time favorite childhood book. Boys, periods, boobs, faith...Thank you Judy Blume for writing a realistic novel that helped me figure some stuff out and avoid awkward conversations with my mom, even though they happened anyways. :))
*Hatchet - Gary Paulsen (so hardcore. I was slightly terrified by this book.)
*Babysitters Club and Sweet Valley High (aaahh literary junk food)
Great post! Keep em' coming!
Soup by Robert Newton Peck
ReplyDeleteSideways Stories from Wayside School by Louis Sachar
A light in the Attic by Shel Silverstein
A New Kid on the Block by Jack Prelutsky
Dune By Frank Herbert
Encylopedia Brown by Donald Sobol
James and the Giant Peach by Roald Dahl
I simiarly loved Hatchet and the entire little house on the prairie series(except all those happy golden years)
and Post adolescence my new favorites is A series of unfortunate event by Lemony Snicket